High Bacteria Readings for Local Waters
Photo of the Week: Cousins in Summer

Hating on the "Rain Tax"? CBF Rebuttal Will Make You Reconsider

The following op-ep originally appeared on Baltimore Fishbowl earlier this week.

Photo by © Krista Schlyer/iLCP.

Before this year the average Marylander probably knew little about stormwater. Environmentalists used the word. But then, environmentalists do weird things, like pay higher prices for food grown locally.

All that changed April 12. Comedian and Fox News commentator Steven Crowder used the phrase "rain tax" in a Fox Business News segment with anchor Neil Cavuto. They ridiculed Maryland (and its Democratic governor) and specifically utility fees dedicated to reducing polluted runoff.

You have to give it to Fox. They know how to make people sit up and get angry. Critics of the fees in Maryland started using the term "rain tax." Reporters picked it up in their stories. Suddenly it was in headlines across the state (first in quotes, then without), most recently in Robert O'Brien's blog in Baltimore Fishbowl, "Nobody Should Like This New Rain Tax, Here's Why."

The whole thing reminded me of when my social studies teacher called on a funny kid in class during a lesson on the Louisiana Purchase. His response got us all laughing. Suddenly we were all paying attention. But we didn't learn much more about the Louisiana Purchase.

In the same way, the "rain tax" hype has made Marylanders generally aware of stormwater, but much of the coverage of the topic doesn't really teach us enough about the problem. While people are still paying attention let me slip in a few facts:

  • This type of pollution is the only major source of water pollution increasing in Maryland.
  • Rain washes dog waste, litter, fertilizer, and other contaminants straight into local creeks, rivers, the Baltimore Inner Harbor, and the Bay. This polluted soup isn't treated in most places.
  • In many areas of the state, polluted runoff is responsible for a major portion of pollution in local rivers and streams.
  • The Maryland Department of the Environment cautions the public not to swim in ANY waterways of the state for 48 hours after a significant storm because stormwater carries harmful bacteria into those waters.
  • If we do this work, not only will our kids be able to safely swim in the water, but we'll create 178,000 full-time private sector jobs in the region, according to the Economic Policy Institute.
  • The state legislature last year budgeted tens of millions of dollars to help local governments reduce this problem, but also decided Baltimore City and the state's most populated counties should pony up, too, because that's where the problem is worse. The localities were asked to raise a fee dedicated only to upgrading their local stormwater systems.
  • Local governments asked that they be given flexibility to decide the size of the fee, and the way it was collected. So it was no surprise this year, when different counties passed different fees, one county as low as one cent per household per year.

And here's one last thing missing from most lampoons of the "rain tax:" an alternative solution. Should we continue to ignore this problem? Should we siphon off money from other government services to upgrade our stormwater systems?

I'm willing to pay a little more for a valuable government service, just as I'm willing to pay more for meat from a steer grown here in Maryland. I see value in that investment. But some people just want the least expensive product.

By setting its own stormwater fee, whether one cent or something higher, each local government made a similar decision.

—Tom Zolper, CBF's Maryland Communications Coordinator

Learn more about Maryland's stormwater fees here.


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Your Information

(Name and email address are required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)