Chesapeake Born: Bay Saving Lessons Learned, Looking Back
A Make-Or-Break Moment for the "Most Important Fish in the Sea"

More Menhaden, More Bait, More Jobs

The following op-ed appeared in The Roanoke Times earlier this week. 

Menhaden photoThe next few months will be crucial for Atlantic menhaden, a small, silvery fish vital to the Chesapeake Bay and the Atlantic Coast. Also called pogie, fatback, and bunker, menhaden have been dubbed "the most important fish in the sea" because of their critical ecological and economic roles.

Menhaden are a major food source for striped bass, bluefish, weakfish, summer flounder, dolphin, whales, ospreys, loons, and pelicans. They are also the target of Virginia’s largest fishery, based in Reedville, that catches and converts menhaden to fish meal and oil. Menhaden are also harvested for bait to catch blue crabs and a variety of sport fish.

The Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission, a partnership of coastal states from Maine to Florida, is considered the unbiased arbiter of menhaden science along the Atlantic Coast. In 2010 and 2012, the commission published stock assessments of the menhaden population that raise very troubling issues and indicate the need for greater conservation of menhaden.

Both ASMFC's 2010 and 2012 assessments clearly showed the menhaden population at or near all-time lows, or about eight percent of what an unfished population would be. Also, the number of young fish entering the population each year has remained remarkably low for nearly 20 years, a serious sign the population is not healthy.

The menhaden fishing industry has questioned ASMFC's science and consistently denied that menhaden are in trouble. ASMFC's peer-reviewed data, however, paint a much different picture, showing the population is experiencing overfishing and has been for at least 32 of the past 54 years.

The industry also contends menhaden numbers today are the same as 50 years ago, implying all is well, but neglecting that 50 years ago the population had plummeted and was declared overfished.

Finally, the industry uses the threat of massive job losses to argue against harvest reductions. However, there once were numerous menhaden industrial plants up and down the East Coast, employing thousands of workers. Today, with menhaden numbers the lowest on record, those fisheries have severely contracted. The Reedville plant is the only one left.

Is maintaining the status quo really the best course for the industry? In the long term, conserving menhaden will restore jobs, not destroy them.

Clearly, more aggressive steps must be taken to protect the menhaden population to enhance both the coastal ecosystem and menhaden-related jobs. The Chesapeake Bay Foundation calls upon the ASMFC to produce a robust menhaden conservation plan when it meets on Dec. 14, and for the Virginia General Assembly to approve its implementation during its 2013 legislative session.

—Chris Moore
CBF's Hampton Roads Senior Scientist


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Captain Cook Hotel

Conserving menhaden will restore jobs, not destroy them, and benefit the ecosystem and the economy.Overfishing must end, if we are to restore menhaden and support the thousands of jobs that depend on healthy coastal ecosystems.


Many women nowadays are turning to replica handbag as compared to buying the original one thus making markets very competitive. This has also been as a result of the fact that designer handbags are too expensive and not many people can afford to put up with their heavy prices therefore resulting Gucci replica to buying replicas which are a bit cheap. However, that matters little as the most important thing is for you to look smart and good in what you wear or have to complement your wear therefore you will need to go a step further to look for the best and affordable replica handbag. For that reason, shopping online is a very applicable option to get the Louis vuitton handbag or any other type you are out looking for and these tips will offer a guideline for you in case you choose to go that way.Unless the price is of no object to you, the designer purses and handbags can ideally be substituted with their faux brand counterparts. There really is no difference opting to replica handbags go down this route when it comes to designer wear.The cost of the authentic fashion accessory can be so overpriced, that it affectively creates its own competition. I know many of the top designers do not like this development, but when you consider the inflated pricing of their purses and handbags, they are the main cause for the problems that they are now facing.There is no problem when a product is priced reasonably for its uniqueness, but if you price that product to high, then you effectively create a parallel market that is capable of duplicating your product and selling it at a price that is significantly lower, because of the relatively cheap costs of manufacturing. Yes, there are patent and replica bags copyright laws, but the ridiculous pricing of these products is an issue that cannot be easily ignored.The designer purse, wallet and handbag are accessories that will for the time being, also be a part of a woman's fashion sense, there's no question about that, but to try and impose restrictions on faux designer wear is a pointless endeavour. They are parallel markets, which mean they both drive one another, with supply and demand being driven by desire and costs.

The comments to this entry are closed.